American Idol Original Fourth Judge Stryker Dropped Out May 2026

It’s one of Idol ’s great “what ifs.” Stryker’s radio background might have given him a sharper, more articulate critique than Dunkleman, potentially leading to a four-judge dynamic that worked. Instead, his last-minute exit gave us the short-lived Dunkleman era and indirectly cemented the iconic trio that launched a thousand karaoke careers.

The result was awkward. Dunkleman was funny but musically out of his depth, often relegated to nodding along to Randy or making jokes that fell flat. The panel of Cowell, Abdul, Jackson, and Dunkleman lasted only one season. For Season 2, Dunkleman was unceremoniously dropped, and the show moved forward with just three judges—a format that would define the next 13 seasons. american idol original fourth judge stryker dropped out

Today, Stryker remains a beloved figure in Los Angeles radio (now on ALT 98.7), while American Idol fans mostly remember the original fourth judge as a trivia answer. But the story is a reminder: the Idol we know almost had a very different voice at the table—until that voice said, “Thanks, but I’m staying on the radio.” It’s one of Idol ’s great “what ifs

Before Simon Cowell’s brutal honesty, Paula Abdul’s tearful kindness, and Randy Jackson’s “yo, dawg,” there was a fourth name on the original American Idol judge’s docket: John "Stryker" Myhre. Dunkleman was funny but musically out of his

But just days before the official premiere, Stryker dropped out.

In the whirlwind months leading up to the summer 2002 premiere of American Idol: The Search for a Superstar , producers at FremantleMedia were scrambling to assemble a panel that had the right chemistry. They had the pop star (Paula), the industry mogul (Simon), the musician (Randy), and they wanted one more voice—a fresh, young, radio-savvy personality to bridge the gap to the teen demographic. Their choice was Stryker, a popular Los Angeles radio personality on alternative rock station KROQ.

Stryker (born John Myhre) was known for his sharp wit, quick interviews, and a “man of the people” energy. He fit the mold of what producers initially envisioned: the warm, relatable counterpoint to Simon’s cold critiques. He attended early audition tapings, sat in the producer’s chair, and provided feedback to nervous contestants.